theodore M I R A L D I mpa ... editor, publisher, writer. katherine molé mfa ... art director

Saturday, October 20, 2018

Coddling the CLOSED American MIND

Illustration on the coddled generation by Alexander Hunter/The Washington Times
Illustration on the coddled generation by Alexander Hunter

Suzanne Fields

Every generation looks back at the one that follows and asks, “What went wrong?” The answers find multiple causes inside the family and outside in politics, offering fragmented and provocative insights into how we got to the America we live in today.
World War II veterans, for example, returned home to enjoy the values they thought they had fought to preserve and the generation they spawned radically changed all that. “Make love not war,” brought on a rebellious hedonism among baby boomers protesting the Vietnam War, inflicting collateral damage in the mores and manners held dear by their parents. “The Spock-marked” generation, as some parents called their offspring in the 1960s, was indulged by the permissive parenting prescribed in the baby-care book by Dr. Benjamin Spock that became a bible for inexperienced parents.
Whether by toilet training or permissiveness, perspectives changed.
A decade later Christopher Lasch identified a culture of narcissism and blamed new experts pushing a psychology emphasizing self-esteem. Decadence and defiance trumped kinship and responsibility in the therapeutic society where medicalized acts of “attitude” diminished standards of accountability.
Allan Bloom at the University of Chicago of the 1980s found college students refusing to sublimate their libido into reading great works of philosophy and literature, eager to let it all hang out, “closing the American mind.” Socratic questioning and sublime reasoning were reduced to nonconformist relativism.
All of these generalizations and catch phrases have as many exceptions as books espousing them, of course, but they make us look harder at the changes shaping the current generation.
With an intentional, if wry reference to Allan Bloom’s “The Closing of the American Mind,” a new book of trendy thinking is called “The Coddling of the American Mind.” It’s written by two authors who bring diverse talents to cultural criticism. Greg Lukianoff, a lawyer and fierce defender of free speech, is president of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE), and Jonathan Haidt, is a social psychologist and professor of Ethical Leadership at New York University. They ask how good intentions and bad ideas are setting up a generation for failure. Sound familiar?
The focus is on the generation following the millennials, popularly known as “iGen”, born in the mid-‘90s and growing up with the Internet in their pocket. Many of these iGens, no matter how savvy with the iPhone withdraw from life and seek protection from the slings and arrows of their outrageous fortune, which often turns out to be an elite college where they insist on protection from the slightest provocation.
These fragile seekers of safe spaces often try to keep speakers who disagree with them from being heard, lest they awaken prejudicial impulses. They demand trigger warnings to prepare them for reading classics of literature that threaten their psychological equilibrium with reminders of tragic events, real or imagined, in their own lives. Sophocles and Shakespeare be damned.
The iGens in this scenario are passive aggressors determined to dictate new rules to protect their virtuous vulnerabilities. To do this they join mobs tyrannizing politically incorrect teachers, administrators, classmates and guest speakers. The noise of the censor rules the land, or at least the campus. The authors call this “vindictive protectiveness. “
We’ve all heard examples of the snowflakes who cultivate their personalized post-traumatic stresses to ruin the lives of others, but Mr. Lukianoff and Mr. Haidt provide a larger framework for pointing out how this dangerous corrupting and corroding academic corner of college culture finds echoes in the larger world.
Instead of confronting their fears and dealing with them, they justify them by making them political. It doesn’t matter so much for those whose parents are willing to pay the high fees of collegiate baby sitters and safety nets, since they will probably cushion the future of their adult children. But college is supposed to be the training ground for future leaders, where the young emerge from their teens to test tough ideas in the arena of robust debate with more than polarizing rhetoric and aggressive behavior.
Members of this generation pose a problem for everyone’s future. The mobs protesting the Kavanaugh confirmation are the most recent example of emotional reasoning gone wild, getting in the face of the senators in elevators and hallways in the Capitol.
The authors of “The Coddling of the America Mind,” argue that many of the iGens receiving so much attention today were overprotected in home and school, even playgrounds, where small hurts are nurtured rather than overcome and fears are dramatized and exaggerated in a retreat from life’s challenges. They recommend an epigraph from folk wisdom for raising the next generation: Prepare the child for the road, not the road for the child. “Then look out for the potholes.”


  1. Dating apps open a globe of choice to you.

  2. Howdy just wanted to give you a quick heads
    up. The text in your content seem to be running off the screen in Firefox.

    I'm not sure if this is a format issue or something
    to do with browser compatibility but I figured I'd post to let you
    know. The style and design look great though! Hope you
    get the problem solved soon. Kudos

  3. Hi there! I know this is kinda off topic however , I'd figured I'd ask.
    Would you be interested in trading links or maybe guest writing a blog article
    or vice-versa? My site covers a lot of the same topics as yours and I believe we could greatly benefit from each other.
    If you might be interested feel free to shoot me an e-mail.

    I look forward to hearing from you! Great blog by the way!

  4. Hello there, We are certainly grateful I’ve
    encountered this data. Nowadays folks post
    much more than rumours and word wide web and that
    is in reality frustrating. An excellent web page by way of stimulating article
    content, this is exactly what I require. Appreciation for retaining
    this site, I am checking out the idea. Is the next step for newsletters?
    Won't be able to think it's.

  5. appreciate it word wide web internet websites.

  6. I'm proposed this website by just my best uncle.

    I’m unsure it doesn't matter if this post is
    constructed simply by your pet as nobody else are aware of like in depth concerning your issue.

    You’re incredible! Thanks a lot!

  7. I am away temporarly, but this time From the why I used to cherish this web site.
    With thanks , I¡¦ll aim to return more often. How many
    times anyone keep track of site?

  8. Mention, you have a wonderful text.Many thanks.

  9. Thank you , Concerning ended up researching the specifics of this kind of content for ages and also
    your business opportunity is the greatest I’ve noticed until
    now. However, precisely what in regards to the finish?
    Are you sure in connection with supply?

  10. Image omitted temporarly, however Walking out to the reason why
    I did previously take pleasure in this web page. With thanks , I am going to
    try to look more regularly. How many times anyone keep track of webpage?

  11. thanks a ton cyberspace internet websites.

  12. With thanks , I’ve happen to be seeking more knowledge about that subject matter for ages plus your own is the greatest
    There are through right up until at this time. However,
    whatever with regard to the realization? Are
    you presently constructive with regards to the supply?

  13. Published prudent review. All of us & my favorite
    friend were being simply able to study regarding
    it. We got a good snap up the sunday paper from neighborhood study
    nonetheless imagine That i perfected more out of this blog post.
    We are fairly seriously happy to check out these sort
    of brilliant knowledge being shared commonly to be found.

  14. Howdy my dearly loved one! I will are convinced that this
    article is remarkable, great drafted and are avalable along with nearly all
    vital infos. I¡¦d want to see increased articles like this .

  15. I like this approach website considerably, The nation's
    some really nice billet to look over and then
    find tips . “The society fails every body, and even later, many are tough on the ruined websites.” with John Hemingway.

  16. thanks a lot net online sites.

  17. terrific challenges once and for all, you recently gotten a whole new website reader.
    Whatever will probably an individual endorse in regards to a person's send in which you made a couple of days previously?

    Any favourable?

  18. You truly ensure it is look so simple using your speech although i look
    for this condition to remain genuinely an item I reckon I
    probably would rarely have an understanding of.
    It seems like likewise complex extremely large personally.
    Now i'm excited for your upcoming place, I'm going to seek to get used to it all!

  19. Hi there i will be kavin, its my 1st opportunity posting comments somewhere, when i just read the piece of writing i believed i possibly could
    even make brief review due to this approach beneficial document.

  20. Howdy. I found your blog utilizing aol. That is a actually written short article.
    I’ll make sure that you store that accessible back to
    read more of one's important specifics. Wanted submit.
    I'm going to undoubtedly comeback.

  21. Hiya, I’m definitely lucky I’ve observed this info.
    These days blog upload just rumours and then total and that is really frustrating.
    A good quality blog by way of useful subject matter, that’s some tips i have
    to have. Appreciate continuing to keep the site, I’ll turn out to be travelling to it again. Happens for newsletters?
    Simply cannot discover it.

  22. Sup pleasant websites!! Person .. Wonderful .. Exceptional ..
    I’ll save your items your web blog and also make
    provides nourishment to also¡KI’m ecstatic to seek out numerous
    helpful facts listed here in the submit, we would like build even more methods
    in this particular aspect, i appreciate you for giving.
    . . . . .

  23. Superb things from your website, fella. I’ve know the equipment just before and you simply basically
    quite terrific. I want what you have developed there,
    appreciate what you are currently revealing and exactly how in places you say it.
    You create them interesting but you just look after to maintain the
    idea prudent. We can’t hang around to learn alot more away from you.
    This really is a beautiful webpage.

  24. Computer software packages for instance Webroot SecureAnywhere Anti-virus irritates malware in a
    couple of means. The idea states computer data and additionally hinders microbes that hot
    weather detects. And it also purges spyware which may be now lodged inside of a laptop.

    You can easily enlighten that in order to read your personal
    machine in keeping with an agenda that you decide on.

  25. esmtie,Your blog appeared to be beneficial together with precious with
    myself. Thank you for spreading.

  26. Ahaa, it really is beneficial controversy relating to this content here at it blog
    page, Concerning learn everything, thus me too commentinghere.

  27. warm regards word wide web webpages.

  28. You really cause it to might seem very simple utilizing your presentation having said that i obtain this trouble to become genuinely
    something which It looks like I'd personally certainly not grasp.
    It seems extremely problematic and vast to do. We're excited for your next place, I may make sure to learn the software!

  29. With thanks , I’ve been on the lookout for the specifics of
    this valuable content for a long time as well as yours works miracles I've found out there until finally today.
    Yet, exactly what about the realization? Are you advantageous for the quantity?

  30. Hey there. superb task. I didnrrrt otherwise this could happen. This is usually a exceptional article.

    Thanks a lot!

  31. Gday, anyone accustomed to compose terrific, however final numerous blogposts are actually fairly boring¡K I actually overlook the enormous
    documents. Last many items are a amount outside of observe!


  32. You possess observed very fascinating points !

    ps3 decent web site. “We basically rob ourselves if we get offers on the dry.” by means of Publilius Syrus.

  33. I¡¦ve just lately initiated an online site, the text you offer members assists
    myself vastly. Thank you for each of your time & job.

  34. Thanks a lot , We've been on the lookout for info on this approach field for
    a long time in addition to yours is the perfect I’ve
    uncovered until now. Nevertheless, which within the conclusion? Are you sure for the useful resource?

  35. Gday pleasant website!! Fella .. Excellent .. Extraordinary ..
    I'm going to save your web page as well as grab the nourishes additionally¡KI morning ready to choose a lot of advantageous
    info a content, political figures acquire supplemental strategies using this esteem, i appreciate you for discussing.

    . . . . .

  36. You've made a lot of high-quality issues in that respect there.
    I did so specific searches to the situation uncovered a lot of workers will have similar opinion using your blog page.

  37. I really like the particular handy specifics one
    give you in the posts. I’ll bookmark your items your web site and appearance over again listed here commonly.
    I’m very without a doubt I’ll learn about lots
    of new stuff here! Undertaking for an additional pair!