theodore M I R A L D I mpa ... editor, publisher, writer. katherine molé mfa ... art director

Friday, May 17, 2019

Texas Asserts SOVEREIGN Immunity AGAINST Congress

Attorney General Ken Paxton's office says that as a state with sovereign powers under the Constitution, Texas can't be treated like a federal agency or Cabinet secretary who can be compelled to comply. (Associated Press)
Attorney General Ken Paxton’s office says that as a state with sovereign powers under the Constitution, Texas can’t be treated like a federal agency or Cabinet secretary who can be compelled to comply. (Associated Press)

Stephen Dinan

Texas is asserting its sovereign immunity against Congress, telling Democrats on two congressional committees this week that the state has no obligation to comply with their investigative demands.
Attorney General Ken Paxton’s office says that as a state with sovereign powers under the Constitution, Texas can’t be treated like a federal agency or Cabinet secretary who can be compelled to comply.
“Texas does not draw its authority from the United States or the United States Constitution, but from its status as a dual sovereign within the union,” Jeffrey C. Mateer, first assistant attorney general, wrote in a letter Monday to the House Oversight and Reform Committee.
Mr. Mateer fired off a similar letter Wednesday to the House Ways and Means Committee rebuffing its attempts, saying the state wouldn’t stand to be treated like a “subdivision of the federal government or a private citizen.”
“Granting Congress the power to exercise ‘oversight’ over the constitutional officers of a state engaged in the lawful exercise of that state’s core authority would undermine the fabric of our system of dual sovereignty,” Mr. Mateer wrote.
The defiance in some ways tracks that of President Trump, who has said House Democrats’ investigations into the president’s business, family and myriad official actions are harassment.
Texas is objecting to Democrats’ requests for documents probing the state’s efforts to clean up its voter rolls, and documents detailing the state’s efforts to protect faith-based adoption and foster care providers against an Obama-era rule about working with same-sex couples.
The clash could break new legal ground.
Ken Cuccinelli, a former Republican attorney general in Virginia, said he never encountered the situation during his time in office, but he added that two constitutional principles are at stake: the sovereignty of states and the supremacy clause, which gives the federal government an edge in clashes with states.
He said Texas makes a strong case in its letters for why it will prevail.
Congress doesn’t get to do oversight over states — period. Nor can they compel action by state officers,” he said. “If I were a betting man, I’d take Texas and give two touchdowns on this one.”
Josh Blackman, a professor at the South Texas College of Law in Houston, said the House committees have issued requests only for documents. Things will get more complicated if either committee feels strongly enough to approve subpoenas.
Mr. Blackman said Texas could try to head that off by suing first, picking a court in Texas and asking for a temporary restraining order against having to turn over any documents while the state argues its case that its officers aren’t subject to federal demands.
He said prior Supreme Court cases have held that Congress can’t “commandeer” a state to enact laws, nor can it force state officials to perform tasks such as run background checks on firearms purchases.
“I usually think of commandeering in the context of legislation, but I don’t see any reason why you have to limit it to legislation,” he said. “It’s [that] Congress can’t give orders pursuant to legislative powers to tell states what to do.”
Neither the oversight nor Ways and Means committee responded to requests for comment on Texas’ challenge, nor did the office of Rep. Jamie Raskin, the Maryland Democrat who chairs an oversight subcommittee looking into the voting issue.
After a previous exchange, though, the oversight committee brushed aside Texas’ claims of sovereignty and insisted that the information would eventually be turned over.
Investigating the states is not new to Congress.
In recent years, the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee investigated the drinking water problem in Flint, Michigan, sparring with then-Gov. Rick Snyder over access to state documents.
It also investigated Oregon’s implementation of its Obamacare website, finding enough fault to ask for criminal charges to be brought against state officials.
In these new cases, the oversight committee is probing Texas’ announcement this year that it found some 95,000 names on voter rolls it suspected of being noncitizens. The state moved to begin to purge the names, drawing a lawsuit from Hispanic and voters rights groups. The sides reached a settlement last month.
The Ways and Means investigation, meanwhile, deals with a request Texas made last year to the federal Health and Human Services Department asking to be freed from Obama-era rules denying assistance to states that certify faith-based adoption or foster parent organizations that won’t work with same-sex couples.
Mr. Mateer, in his letters, said the committees are entitled to ask federal agencies for information they have, including communications with Texas. He also said they are entitled to any documents from Texas that a citizen would be able to get through the state’s open records laws.
The Texas attorney general’s office also questioned the validity of the committees’ inquiries, saying they haven’t identified a valid legislative purpose. The Supreme Court has held that while Capitol Hill has broad investigative powers, they must be tethered to some lawmaking, either now or with the prospect of legislating.
That is the same argument the Trump administration made this week in objecting to the expansive document demands from the House Judiciary Committee, which is looking to redo and expand on the special counsel’s report into the 2016 election and Russian meddling.
In the case of the voting inquiry, Mr. Mateer said there is no right for noncitizens to vote, so there is nothing Congress could legislate over.


  1. I have been surfing online more than 4 hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours.
    It’s pretty worth enough for me. In my opinion, if all webmasters and bloggers made good content
    as you did, the web will be a lot more useful than ever before.

    I have been browsing online greater than 3 hours lately, but I never
    found any fascinating article like yours. It is pretty
    value enough for me. In my opinion, if all site owners and bloggers
    made just right content as you probably did, the web might be much more helpful than ever before.
    I could not refrain from commenting. Very well written!

  2. Therefore, once you hqve to ggo via a process, try tto discover the finest way so that
    you ccan obtain the desird lead to not only the horter time butt additionally is capable of it inside the best
    way. One downside to that is obviously you never actually begin to see the piece 'face to
    face' which may be a disadvantage when purchasing designer products.
    Though the web sites have riisen in number but a majority of everyone is sometimes confused
    and they also couldn't make sound decision that
    that store they must buy their stuff.

  3. In each and every season people use to eatt appropriately,
    work appropriately and experience the environment appropriately.
    With other cloud sgorage programs the apps were simple to use, aas well as aany files opened
    up directly within my Think - Free Office where I could start editing.
    Just make sure tht you just take just as muh tike since you
    need to really run through no lss than a number off the different caar shelters
    which can bee available web within your area.

  4. Cracked slate have to be replaced instantly to stop leak troubles that migbht just after customize the underlayment.
    When you're nereding building and restoration work doing andd requre thee help of aan experiebced professional, Todco
    Roofing Ltd. Apart from your residential services, professionals
    in the region also provide assistance for commercial roofing Chicago buildinhg owners may be thinking about.

  5. I found myself advocated your blog just by the relative.
    I’m confused no matter whether this post is constructed simply by
    your pet since who else be aware of these types of precise concerning this bother.
    You happen to be superb! With thanks!

  6. The truth that in which you are obtaining your facts,
    nonetheless very good content. Simply put i must invest
    some time discovering far more and also being familiar with even more.
    Appreciate your sharing magnificent info I have been interested in this article in my quest.

  7. Thank you for various other enlightening website. The location better might I
    receive which usually particular information written in a really best procedure?
    I get a venture which I’m just now doing, not to mention I’ve happened to be on the
    seek out this kind of info.

  8. Every weekend i used to go to see this site, as i
    want enjoyment, since this this site conations really pleasant funny
    material too.

  9. For newest information you have to pay a visit world-wide-web and on the web
    I found this site as a best web page for hottest