theodore M I R A L D I mpa ... editor, publisher, writer

Friday, May 17, 2019

Trump’s Plan To REFORM Legal Immigration Is Long OVERDUE

Shifting immigration away from family reunification and toward skills-based employment is something the United States should have done long ago.

Trump’s Plan To Reform Legal Immigration Is Long Overdue

John Daniel Davidson

The immigration plan President Trump unveiled in a speech yesterday afternoon seems to have something in it for everyone to hate. Immigration hardliners on the right are upset it doesn’t include a reduction in overall immigration levels. Opponents on the left—who were never going to support a Trump plan, regardless of its merits—say it’s a non-starter because it doesn’t include a path to citizenship for those who illegally crossed the border as minors.

But this lack of support says more about the irreconcilable differences between left and right than it does about the virtues of the proposal itself, which are considerable.

At its most basic level, Trump’s plan aims to reshape our immigration system by prioritizing employment instead of family reunification. Other elements to the plan include bolstering border security and reforming the asylum system, but the most important proposed change is the shift to a “merit-based” system for legal immigration.

Why is that such a big deal? Because the United States, unique among developed countries, maintains a quixotic and outdated immigration system—created in 1965—in which the vast majority of immigrants are admitted through family reunification, often referred to as “chain migration,” and for good reason. If someone comes to the United States on a work visa, he can sponsor his adult parents, who in turn can sponsor their relatives, and so on. When Trump said in his speech Thursday that we’re admitting people based on “random chance,” this, along with our visa lottery system, is what he’s talking about.

Countries like Canada, Australia, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, and Japan don’t do this. They use a points-based system that prioritizes visas for certain kinds of workers. In Canada, for example, there’s no visa lottery, and the vast majority of immigrants are admitted as part of economic programs to meet skills shortages in the labor market. The Canadian points-based system includes categories like education, proficiency in English and French, age, and work experience. Same with Australia and the United Kingdom.

Trump is essentially proposing such a system for the United States. His plan envisions a “Build America visa” that incorporates parts of Sen. Tom Cotton’s 2017 RAISE Act, awarding points based on things like age, special skills, a job offer, an advanced education, and a plan to create jobs.

While the details are still scant—Trump’s announcement Thursday wasn’t accompanied by a bill or any legislative language—the administration is essentially proposing a system that looks a lot like what other peer countries have. As it is, Trump said, “We discriminate against genius, we discriminate against brilliance,” which in a sense we do. To the extent Trump wants to change that, he’s on the right track.

Of course, some on the left will characterize this, as one Vox reporter did, as “keeping the poors out,” when in reality it would merely bring U.S. immigration policy into alignment with what the rest of the developed world does.

Imperfection Is Not A Good Reason to Oppose This Plan

As a practical matter, if Trump’s plan ever became policy it would likely dramatically increase immigration from Asia. More than 80 percent of those whose employment-based visas have been approved but are held up by annual caps live in China, India, and the Philippines. A majority of immigrants from Asia have bachelor’s degrees, and would therefore have a decided advantage in vying for work visas under this new system.

That said, the plan unveiled Thursday has almost no chance of becoming law. It’s effectively a 2020 campaign document, meant to define what the Trump administration—and by extension, the GOP—supports, and force Democrats to react to it. But that’s another reason immigration hawks on the right, like the Center for Immigration Studies’ Mark Krikorian, oppose it. “Formally embracing the current legal-immigration level of more than one million each year would mean that the GOP, as on so many issues before, would simply be the Democrat-lite party, wanting to go in the same direction, just more slowly,” writes Krikorian.

Another mark against the plan, at least for some conservatives, is that it doesn’t address the current border crisis, which is being driven by Central American families and minors seeking asylum after illegally crossing the southwest border. A bill unveiled Wednesday by Sen. Lindsey Graham would tackle this, requiring Central Americans to apply for asylum in their home countries, increasing the amount of time families and children can be detained, from 20 days to 100, and adding 500 judges to tackle a massive backlog of immigration cases.

Whatever the particular complaints the right might have with the administration’s proposed immigration overhaul, conservatives should at least by able to agree that the current, 1960s-era system has outlived its usefulness and that we need a modernized immigration system that puts the American economy and American interests first. That’s the direction Trump’s plan would take us, and it’s about time.



  1. Anonymous2:34 PM EDT

    You need to sign up to administrator Vy Nguyen Cao understand
    how to care for young people shared located at Caolonkhoemanh website.
    # caolonkhoemanh, Number vynguyencao

  2. Anonymous5:06 PM EDT

    You first need tto identify a nikche market, and then build-up your internet site to
    a position about where it may contend with these generic terms.
    Advertised shrtcuts and file types both encourage the above behavior,
    and also repir a damaged application by copying missing filess when they are invoked.
    Retail stores online formula for achievement depended heavily onn advertising, it advertised oon famous social networks and appearance engines.

  3. Anonymous4:37 AM EDT

    This was it, i was searching for. Thanks a lot for taking some time to release it on your post.
    Truly Appreciated. I will be visiting your blog again as i just found you publish such an amazing stuff here.

    Also i determined a website which is devoted to people who aspire to loose weight eventually.
    It's about Keto Body Tone that is getting popular in the USA,
    and they are concerning other countries too. Hope you might love to
    inspect it out and share your views about Keto Body Tone Diet Product.

  4. Anonymous8:47 AM EDT

    It's nearly impossible to find knowledgeable people for
    this topic, however, you sound like you know what you're talking about!

  5. Anonymous1:01 PM EDT

    Hey there! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any problems with hackers?
    My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing months of hard work
    due to no backup. Do you have any methods to prevent hackers?

  6. Anonymous2:45 PM EDT

    What i do not realize is in fact how you are now not actually a lot more neatly-liked than you
    may be right now. You're very intelligent. You realize
    therefore considerably in the case of this topic, produced
    me in my view imagine it from numerous various angles.
    Its like women and men are not fascinated except it is something to accomplish with Lady gaga!
    Your individual stuffs nice. All the time maintain it up!

  7. Anonymous4:04 PM EDT

    You actually make it appear really easy
    along with your presentation but I in finding this matter to be actually something which I believe
    I would by no means understand. It kind of feels too complex and extremely wide for me.
    I am having a look ahead to your subsequent post,
    I will try to get the grasp of it!

  8. Anonymous10:54 AM EDT

    I think the admin of this web site is in fact working hard in favor of his web site, because here every stuff
    is quality based material.

  9. Anonymous12:53 AM EDT

    I got this site from my buddy who shared with me on the topic
    of this website and at the moment this time I am browsing this web site and reading very informative articles at this place.

  10. Anonymous9:27 AM EST

    I could not refrain from commenting. Perfectly written!