theodore M I R A L D I mpa ... editor, publisher, writer. katherine molé mfa ... art director

Monday, June 17, 2019

Roe v. Wade Speculation? Clarence Thomas Calls for Abandoning 'DEMOSTRABLY ERRONEOUS' Precedent

 Gregg Re

In a concurring opinion in a Supreme Court case announced Monday, Justice Clarence Thomas issued a lengthy call for his colleagues to overturn "demonstrably erroneous decisions" even if they have been upheld for decades -- prompting legal observers to say Thomas was laying the groundwork to overturn the seminal 1973 case Roe v. Wade, which established a constitutional right to abortion.
Thomas' blunt opinion came in a case concerning the so-called "double-jeopardy" doctrine, which generally prohibits an individual from being charged twice for the same crime. But both pro-life and pro-choice advocates quickly noted the implications of his reasoning for a slew of other future cases, including a potential revisiting of Roe.
"When faced with a demonstrably erroneous precedent, my rule is simple: We should not follow it," Thomas wrote, noting that lower federal courts should also disregard poor precedents. Thomas went on to add that precedent "may remain relevant when it is not demonstrably erroneous."
Neal Katyal, a Georgetown Law professor and former Acting Solicitor General of the United States, warned that Thomas' reasoning could have far-reaching implications.
"Justice Thomas is essentially laying the intellectual groundwork for a massive revisiting of settled precedents," Katyal wrote. "This can prove to be very, very dangerous."
Added Slate legal analyst Mark Joseph Stern: "His repudiation of stare decisis isn’t really about Gamble. It’s aimed at a clear set of precedents—those enshrining a constitutional right to abortion access and same-sex marriage."
Thomas' argument began by noting that the role of federal courts is primarily to uphold the Constitution above all else -- and if that means overturning long-held precedents set by other federal courts, Thomas wrote, so be it.
Associate Justice Clarence Thomas wrote in an opinion Monday that precedent should always be secondary to the Constitution. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite)
Associate Justice Clarence Thomas wrote in an opinion Monday that precedent should always be secondary to the Constitution. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite)
"The Constitution tasks the political branches—not the Judiciary—with systematically developing the laws that govern our society," Thomas wrote. "The Court’s role, by contrast, is to exercise the 'Judicial Power,' faithfully interpreting the Constitution and the laws enacted by those branches."
English common law, Thomas said, relied on a precedent-focused principle called "stare decisis," meaning "let the decision stand." But unlike English common law, Thomas asserted, "we operate in a system of written law in which courts need not—and generally cannot—articulate the law in the first instance."
Thomas went on to address several counter-arguments, including the idea that precedent allows for more consistent legal determinations, and more certainty for litigants. He cited, for example, arguments to that effect by Justice Stephen Breyer in previous cases.
"As I see it, we would eliminate a significant amount of uncertainty and provide the very stability sought if we replaced our malleable balancing test with a clear, principled rule grounded in the meaning of the text," Thomas countered. "The true irony of our modern stare decisis doctrine lies in the fact that proponents of stare decisis tend to invoke it most fervently when the precedent at issue is least defensible."
"When faced with a demonstrably erroneous precedent, my rule is simple: We should not follow it."
— Justice Clarence Thomas
Thomas concluded: "In my view, if the Court encounters a decision that is demonstrably erroneous—i.e., one that is not a permissible interpretation of the text—the Court should correct the error, regardless of whether other factors support overruling the precedent. ... A demonstrably incorrect judicial decision ... is tantamount to making law, and adhering to it both disregards the supremacy of the Constitution and perpetuates a usurpation of the legislative power."
Kristen Clarke, the President and Executive Director of the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, told Fox News that Thomas' comments were part of a larger attack on abortion rights.
"One can't ignore the timing of Justice Thomas's concurring opinion which comes at a moment when we are seeing a coordinated and relentless attack on Roe v. Wade across the country," Clarke said. "The laws that have been adopted in several states violate the Court's settled precedent in Roe. In his concurring opinion, Justice Thomas has made clear his willingness to reject precedents that he personally deems incorrect, a position that unnecessarily politicizes the Court.
"Justice Thomas's view is fundamentally at odds with the way in which the Supreme Court has generally operated," Clarke said. "It is a view that threatens to further undermine the integrity of the Court and weaken the stability of the institution."
Thomas, in the Gamble case, ended up joining the court's 7-2 majority in ruling that individuals can be prosecuted by both the state and the federal government for the same crime, without violating the constitution's double jeopardy rules.
The idea, backed by generations of precedent, is that the states and federal government are separate sovereign entities, and that a crime against one is distinct from a crime against the other. That precedent, Thomas ruled, was not demonstrably erroneous, and therefore the majority was justified in following it.
Only the unusual pairing of Neil Gorsuch and Ruth Bader Ginsburg dissented, saying that argument was essentially a loophole to circumvent the Constitution's prohibition against double jeopardy.
"A free society does not allow its government to try the same individual for the same crime until it's happy with the result," Gorsuch wrote.
In the majority opinion, Justice Samuel Alito was more deferential to precedent, saying "special justification" is needed to overturn precedent, even where the Constitution would serve as a lodestar.
Nevertheless, Alito noted that "the strength of the case for adhering to [previous] decisions grows in proportion to their ‘antiquity,'" meaning that newer precedents are less secure than older ones.
Monday's opinion was Thomas' second in as many months to hearten pro-life advocates. In May, Thomas wrote a concurring opinion in a separate case that the Supreme Court would soon have to address the constitutionality of pro-life abortion laws head-on.
The justices, by a 7-2 vote in that case, upheld an Indiana law requiring the cremation or burial of fetal remains -- but they declined to take up the constitutionality of a law that would have barred abortion based on disability, sex, or race.
"Given the potential for abortion to become a tool of eugenic manipulation," Thomas wrote, "the court will soon need to confront the constitutionality of laws like Indiana's," Thomas wrote. "From the beginning, birth control and abortion were promoted as means of effectuating eugenics."


  1. Thank you for the good writeup. It in fact was a amusement
    account it. Look advanced to more added agreeable from you!
    By the way, how could we communicate? Hello would you mind letting me know which web
    host you're using? I've loaded your blog in 3 completely different web browsers and I must say this blog loads
    a lot faster then most. Can you recommend a good web hosting provider at a honest price?
    Many thanks, I appreciate it! I have been surfing online greater
    than 3 hours as of late, yet I by no means discovered any interesting
    article like yours. It's pretty price sufficient for me.
    In my view, if all webmasters and bloggers made good content
    material as you probably did, the internet shall
    be a lot more useful than ever before.

  2. Many people experience the issue of majorr depression, normally, a minimum of, as soon as
    inn their lifestyles. Managing depression might be fairly difficult,
    as people really feel stuck making use of their feelings of misery and despair.
    Nevertheless, regardless how oout off the question it may seem,
    depressive disorders could be encountered.

    The tips on this page may hellp you experience depression.

    Ingesting a well-balanced diet program and ensuring you eeat thee correct uantity of vitamins and nutrients can also be
    necessary to liviing a well healthy and healthful lifestyle.
    Vegatables and fruits are a crucial part of one's diet program,
    and your food consumption has been shown to have very much related to your disposition.

    In the event you bee experiencing mild major depression, thunk about some straightforward,
    over the counter possibilities. Attempt something
    succh as grape fruit juice combined with Saint.

    St. Johns Wart might help your intellectual well being. It will probably be assist
    you to which iss much cheaper than medication medication.

    When you are seeking to overcome depressive disorders, it is actually beneficial to join a support group for despresion symptoms.
    Help groups offer you encouragement from individuals that hsve experienced what yoou arre going
    through. Also you can obtain and present information oon methods on dealing wiuth major depression.
    Getting with others who comprehend what you really are going through
    helps in reducing your sense of solitude.

    You may not particularly bee frustrated should youu just sense fairly lower about
    aan event in your own life. Prikor to deciding to perform a personal prognosis, meet with a skilled.

    Being enthusiastic about a pastime is a great way to assist yoou
    to handle your depressive disorders. Lots of people state thazt
    growing plants is probably the greatest activitoes but it could be whichever interests you.
    Just the action off developing a activity can frequently consider
    yojr brain awway from precisely what is ailing you.

    Depressive dsorders may affect any individual and may have devastating effects should it
    be not treated. The great thing is that major depression is treatable aand remedied tnrough a numbe of tactics for example the ones listed inn this article above.
    Tend not to wait tto seek therapy if you believe you suffer fro depressive disorders or perhaps to aid someone close
    seek treatment if you find signs of depression.

  3. Enhancing your beauty either can be a smart skilled relocate or
    even a exciting private strategy. It will require some energy to
    operate effectively though. This will make you ponder where to begin to
    sstart out developing a sstrategy which fits your life-style.
    Everything you should learn about how to staret with beauty shows up in the following.

    Place Vaseline in your eye-brows prior to going
    too get to sleep. This could increase the style of your eye-brows simply by making yoour hair appear glossier.

    Be careful you don't geet Vaseline anywhere else on the encounter, since it can cause unwelcome breakouts of acne.

    Give coconut essential oiil a shot, as opposed to shelling out lots of
    mney over a pricey moisturizer. Using virgin coconut gas cann
    help soothe the skin minimizing the look of creases and
    faacial lines. It also helps take care of skin conditions like eczema, zits
    and psoriasis because oof its anti-bacterial and anti--candica properties.

    Light or sparse eye-brows could be simply and efficiently filled in so they aare look fuller and larger.
    Make use of a throw-away mascara wand to remember to brush on dim likght brown eyes shadow or mascara into the brows, then hair comb
    it through with another disposable clean to forensic psychology master degree smooth out the shade and
    take away clumps.

    When you have overly spherical eye, you aare able to elonhate them by modifying your eyeliner program.
    The exterior two-thirds of yopur rerspective decrease and top lash collections ought to be lined with a darker brown liner.
    Thee two facial lines should fulfill on the external part of each and every eyes.
    Eventually, utilize two layers of mascara inn your outer top lashes.

    Before you transform iin for the nighht time,
    rinse your cosmetics away and off too save your skin area. You can use a make-up remover or perhaps a washcloth of tepid to warm
    water. In case you have taken out the makeup, utilize your regular natural skin care product.

    In the event you don't get ridd of make-up, it would block your pores and you also are more inclined to get acne breakouts.

    These bauty tips need to hhave you feeling good. There is lots of data right here, but it
    provides you with a concept of how to start a attractiveness strategy.

    Aside from, you can senhd straight bafk to thi collection.

  4. Aftfer going over a number of the blog artidles on your
    website, I seriously appreciate your technique of blogging.
    I book-marked it to my bookmark webpage list and
    will bbe checkming back in thhe near future. Please check out
    my wweb site as well and let me know how you feel.

  5. Ahaa, it's superior talk concerning this document you'll come to that website, We have understand your, so now us too commentinghere.

  6. This is the right blog for everyone who really wants to understand this topic.
    You understand so much its almost hard to argue with you (not that I personally
    would want to…HaHa). You definitely put a new
    spin on a subject that's been discussed for years.

    Excellent stuff, just excellent!